top of page


Travelling home from Devon today so Fifty3 Fridays should return in its regular guise next week. Meanwhile here is a diversion, but a wonderful one at that. Let’s just hope there isn’t a long one on the A303. Actually, I wrote that bit earlier and there wasn’t, though the journey with stops still took seven hours.

Originally I was going to leave this one until October 2022 when it will be 50 years old but, necessity being the mother of invention, let’s dust it off now. So, I present Foxtrot, the fourth studio album – and in my opinion finest – from early prog-meisters, Genesis.

“Walking across the sitting-room, I turn the television off

Sitting beside you, I look into your eyes

As the sound of motor cars fades in the night time

I swear I saw your face change, it didn’t seem quite right.”

Song lyrics are like a treasure trove of memories; good, bad, happy, sad, proud, embarrassing. This particular quatrain kicks off the epic “Supper’s Ready” from the 1972 album by Genesis, Foxtrot, itself a progressive rock landmark for many fans. Well, we used to sing this particular opus from start to finish in a style uncomfortably similar to that later adopted by the guys in Wayne’s World when reprising Queen’s “Bohemian Rhapsody”. So that’s good, happy and almost certainly embarrassing, then.

When you dust off a record that made its first impression on the world almost 49 years ago, it’s tempting to think you can put the clock back at the same time. Thinning hair and middle age spread may tell an opposite tale, but memories can at least be rekindled. In those days, you could recite Genesis and Yes songs word for word, irrespective of their length, and still have time to launch into Monty Python’s Four Yorkshiremen or The Spanish Inquisition in character. And think, The Holy Grail was still to be found. All of which suggests that if a piece of music, or indeed a comedy sketch, held such resonance way back that you can recall it by association right now, it probably wasn’t half bad.

Well, Foxtrot is not half bad. In fact, it’s a great record even if I did fail to shoehorn it into Consequence’s Top 100 Albums Ever. It’s the one where all the promise of the band’s three opening albums is delivered in a cohesive and compelling fashion. Pull out the original vinyl and you get four songs on side one and one on side two. OK, two if you count the lovely 1:41 guitar piece, “Horizons”, which acts as a prelude to the 23-minute splendour that is “Supper’s Ready”. It’s a mighty record full of inscrutable lyrics wholly redeemed by fantastic imagery and enlivened by a surfeit of puns, whimsy, grandiose melodies, eccentricity, instrumental virtuosity and immense vocals. It’s held together by a structure that is simply intuitive. Individually there may be stronger Genesis songs elsewhere in the band’s catalogue than the four that collectively build toward the main event on side two but it’s the contribution to the greater whole that works here.

Foxtrot signals the appearance of one of rock’s odder hairstyles; the centre parting with a section shaved out of the front which, aided by heavy eye make-up gave singer Peter Gabriel a distinctly alien look. Gabriel has always been an innovator and prone to theatricality, not least in this phase when he used to don a fox’s head atop a long red evening dress with Spanish flounced sleeves. Somewhat like the image on the front cover, but without the tits. Guitarist Steve Hackett, bass player Mike Rutherford, together with Tony Banks on keys and drummer Phil Collins, before he rediscovered Motown, offer a studious as much as a stunning canvas for Gabriel’s tongue in cheek histrionics.

The album, though, passed many people by and only reached no. 12 on the UK charts while failing to land at all on the US equivalent. It may have lacked the accessibility of the more commercial prog-rock offerings of the time. It was music to sit cross-legged alongside in awed appreciation, rather than to fully rock out to. In many ways, Foxtrot is a logical outcome of its more darkly introspective predecessor, Nursery Cryme, which deserves a dusting off of its own. That album was most notable for its ambitious 10-minute opener, “The Musical Box”, which paves the way for the episodic, song-within-a-song mastery that was to come in the shape of “Supper’s Ready”.

The opening track on Foxtrot is similarly uncompromising. The grand, Mellotron-charged “Watcher of the Skies” runs for a full two-and-a-half minutes before Peter Gabriel sparks into life and tries to cram the most words into a short line until Michael Stipe voiced “Call me when you try to wake her up” in “The Sidewinder Sleeps Tonight”. “Time Table”, with its musings on the transience of life and sense of resignation at lessons unlearned, and the peculiar, pun-laden tale of futuristic corporate greed, “Get ‘Em Out by Friday”, establish a theme of life repeating itself through different ages. This link is metaphorically extended when we get “Can-Utility and the Coastliners” replaying the legend of King Canute’s fateful attempt to turn back the tide.

Side one is littered with scintillating instrumental breaks and symphonic virtuosity that keeps you enthralled, while Gabriel’s vocal twists and turns, taking on a raft of different personae in his inimitable style. The feast is then delivered by the majestic “Supper’s Ready”, which takes you from a kind of Genesis to Revelations, the humdrum of a TV dinner through to a joyous post-apocalypse, decorated by glorious anthemic hooks and stings. This audacious song is structured in seven parts (let’s not go there) and its huge achievement is to override the pretension that it easily could have fallen foul of. Be prepared to ride a whole gamut of emotions as we encounter love and war, false prophets, man and nature, myth and legend. The transitions between sections are so cleverly worked that the result is almost seamless, despite the mood switches and character take-ons.

A masterpiece, pure and simple.

The much-rescheduled Genesis UK tourThe Last Domino? – features founding members Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford, together with Phil Collins. It kicks off in Dublin on 15 Sept and ends with three dates at London’s O2 Arena (11-13 Oct) after which the band heads off for North America (Nov/Dec). Details HERE.

A version of this article first appeared on in 2010.


FIFTY3 champions

outstanding new music

through Fifty3 Fridays and

occasional features 


Music is a great passion of mine. In my teenage years I was an avid record collector and concert goer. Stints as a booking agent, running folk clubs, promoting gigs and even a crack at artiste management followed. While it never became my main occupation, music was always on my personal radar.


In the past 15 years I have written for leading US music website  Consequence and breakthrough  site, BestNewBands. I am a judge for Glastonbury Festival's Emerging Talent Competition and have reviewed the festival for both sites. I am now pleased to curate my very own music site.


Nothing gives me greater pleasure than unearthing great, original new music and championing independent musicians. You’ll find many of them on this site alongside the occasional legend of times past and I hope they will bring  you as much joy as they give me.

Tony Hardy



Selected dates in the London area:

Thu 23 May: Jon Allen, The Bedford, Balham

Fri 24 May: Grace Cummings, The Lexington, London N1

Thu 30 May: Sweet Billy Pilgrim, Greenleaf  Church, London E17

Fri 7 Jun: Goat Girl, Disco Room - Pryzm, Kingston

Sat 8 Jun: Bat For Lashes, St John's Church, Kingston See the Events page for all live shows in Kingston


  • Twitter B&W
  • Spotify Social Icon
  • LinkedIn Social Icon


bottom of page